The Thinkers of Miletus, from Thales to the First Map
Most books on the history of philosophy start in the same place: on the Aegean coast, at Miletus, right beside Balat in today's Didim district of Aydın.
Sign in to like and rate

Most books on the history of philosophy start in the same place: on the Aegean coast, at Miletus, right beside Balat in today's Didim district of Aydın. In the 6th century BC three thinkers who lived in this harbour city, Thales, Anaximander and Anaximenes, tried to explain what the world is made of and how it works by looking at nature itself. Two more names from the same city followed them: Hecataeus, who put the world into writing and onto a map, and Hippodamus, who planned cities with streets meeting at right angles. This article introduces these five Milesians through what they said and what is attributed to them, and at the end explains how visitors to Miletus can read this story at the site.
Why Miletus
Miletus was one of the richest and most powerful of the Ionian cities. Kültür Portalı writes that it was an important harbour city in the Archaic Age and held the position of capital of the Ionian Confederacy. According to English Wikipedia, in the 6th century BC Miletus had dozens of colonies, spread above all along the shores of the Black Sea; Sinope and Olbia are the best known of them. Ships sailing to distant harbours, trade with other peoples and encounters with different stories created an environment that gathered knowledge and invited questions. The Aydın guidebook of the South Aegean Development Agency also calls Miletus the city of philosophers of antiquity and says it was no coincidence that the foundations of rational thought were laid here.
None of the books these thinkers wrote themselves has survived. We know them largely through the reports of Aristotle and his student Theophrastus, and through compilations by later writers. So every view described below should be read not as their own words but as ideas attributed to them.
Thales and the question of water
Thales was born in the last quarter of the 7th century BC and lived until the middle of the 6th century. He is counted among the Seven Sages of ancient Greece. The idea that made him most famous is the view that everything comes from water. The article by Alper Bilgehan Yardımcı and Fatma Güdücü of Pamukkale University, published on DergiPark, sets out in detail how Aristotle's Metaphysics links this view to Thales. According to the article, Aristotle thought Thales may have been led to the idea by simple observations, such as that the food of every living thing is moist and that seeds have a moist nature.
The point the article stresses is that the importance of Thales lies less in whether his answer was right than in the question he asked. Raising the question of what everything ultimately is opened a new path of inquiry that could be debated, tested and refuted. The authors note that this prepared the ground for explanations based on reason instead of mythological ones. Historians of philosophy give the name Milesian School to exactly this shared attitude.
Other achievements in mathematics and astronomy are also attributed to Thales. According to the ancient accounts quoted by English Wikipedia, in Egypt he found the height of the pyramids by measuring a pyramid's shadow at the moment when his own shadow was equal to his height. He is also said to have been able to calculate the distance of ships at sea from the shore and to have recommended the constellation Ursa Minor to sailors as a guide for navigation. The Thales theorem still taught in geometry lessons today bears his name.
The man who foretold an eclipse
The event most closely linked to the name of Thales is a solar eclipse. The historian Herodotus writes that in the sixth year of the war between the Lydians and the Medes, during a battle, day suddenly turned into night, both armies stopped fighting and made peace, and Thales of Miletus had foretold this, naming the very year in which it happened. The Miletus page of the Ministry of Culture and Tourism also relates that Thales learned to calculate solar eclipses.
Modern calculations identify the eclipse matching the conditions Herodotus describes as that of 28 May 585 BC. Even so, historians of science treat the story with caution. According to the debate summarised by English Wikipedia, at the time it was not yet known that eclipses are caused by the Moon passing between the Earth and the Sun, and no cycle had been identified that could reliably predict an eclipse for a particular place. Even if the story is true, how Thales did it remains uncertain. But that uncertainty is as interesting as the fact that it is still being debated two thousand six hundred years later.
Anaximander and the Earth that floats
Anaximander, a fellow citizen of Thales and, according to the sources, his student, was born around 610 BC. The article by Yardımcı and Güdücü shows clearly where he parted ways with his teacher. Anaximander accepts that everything comes from a first substance, but he thinks it cannot be water or any other particular element. His first principle is the apeiron, something boundless, indefinite and infinite. According to the article, Anaximander tried to answer the question Thales had left open, how so many different things can arise from a single substance, by explaining that hot and cold separated from this principle, that moisture came from them, and then earth and air.
Anaximander's contribution to astronomy was bold as well. According to English Wikipedia, he imagined the Earth as a cylinder whose height was a third of its diameter, hanging in the middle of the universe without resting on anything. Aristotle found this idea ingenious. The thought that the Earth could stay in empty space without falling is counted by many writers, among them the philosopher Karl Popper, as one of the most daring steps in the history of thought. Ancient sources also credit him with writing the first work on nature in prose.
The first map of the world
It is Anaximander, too, who gives Miletus a special place in the history of cartography. As English Wikipedia relates, the geographers Strabo and Agathemerus, drawing on Eratosthenes, write that Anaximander was the first to publish a map of the known world. Maps had been made earlier in Egypt and Babylon; Anaximander's innovation was to show the whole inhabited world known to the Greeks in a single drawing. It is also thought that this map would have served navigation and trade with Miletus's distant colonies.
The same source relates, on the authority of the Byzantine lexicon known as the Suda, that Anaximander introduced to Greece the gnomon, the vertical rod whose shadow shows the time and the seasons, and that he took part in setting up sundials in Sparta that marked the solstices and equinoxes. It adds that the gnomon itself had been used by the Babylonians and that Anaximander brought it into the Greek world.
Anaximenes and the thickening of air
The third name of the school, Anaximenes, was born around 586 or 585 BC and is regarded as a student of Anaximander. Yardımcı and Güdücü explain that he looked for a middle way between his two predecessors. For Anaximenes the first principle is air; in other words, like Thales he chooses a particular substance, but like Anaximander he considers it boundless. According to the article's conclusion, this is why Anaximenes's understanding of substance is more comprehensive than that of the other two thinkers.
Anaximenes's real contribution was to explain change through a process. According to English Wikipedia, he held that as air thickens it turns into wind, cloud, water, earth and finally stone, and as it thins it becomes fire. This is regarded as the first attempt to explain the passage of a substance from one state to another through a physical process. He is said to have observed that breath comes out warm when you open your mouth wide and cold when you blow through pursed lips; although this is the exact opposite of the relation known today, the way he tried to move from an everyday experience to a general rule is remarkable. He is also said to have been the first philosopher to attempt a scientific explanation of the rainbow.
Hecataeus and Hippodamus
The intellectual tradition of Miletus did not end with these three names. Hecataeus, born around 550 BC, improved Anaximander's map according to English Wikipedia and wrote the Periodos Ges, or Journey round the Earth, which describes a voyage along the coasts of the Mediterranean and the Black Sea. More than three hundred fragments of this work have survived. The Ministry's Miletus page also mentions Hecataeus as one of the first to draw a map of the world.
Hippodamus was an architect and town planner who lived in the 5th century BC. His name has been given to the grid plan made of broad, straight streets crossing each other at right angles. English Wikipedia reminds us that right-angled plans were in use before him, but names him as the man who turned this order into a principle of urban design. According to Aristotle he planned Piraeus, the port of Athens. He is also linked with the rebuilding of Miletus, which had been destroyed by the Persian attack in 494 BC. Kültür Portalı notes that Priene was rebuilt in the middle of the 4th century BC according to this plan known by the name of Hippodamus.
Reading these traces at Miletus
There is neither the house of Thales nor the map of Anaximander at the site, but the setting in which this thinking was born can still be read. First climb the steps of the theatre and look west. The gulf where ships once moored is a flat plain today; the sea that gave Miletus its wealth and its link with the wider world was here. Then go down and walk through the streets of the city centre. The grid of streets meeting at right angles is the plan associated with the name of Hippodamus, applied in his own city.
Round off your visit with the Miletus Museum, which can be visited with the same ticket. According to the Ministry's page, the ticket for the archaeological site also covers the museum. If you also stop at nearby Priene, you can see at a glance how the grid plan was laid out on a hillside.
Practical tips
- Miletus lies in the Balat quarter of the Didim district and is easy to reach by car from the direction of Söke and Didim.
- Check the opening hours and entry conditions of the site and the museum's visiting days on the official website before you go.
- The plain is very hot in summer and there is little shade at the site; come early in the morning or late in the afternoon and bring a hat and water.
- Take a short note with the names in this article; stopping to read it at the top of the theatre and in the street grid makes the meaning of the place far more tangible.
Sources
- Alper Bilgehan Yardımcı, Fatma Güdücü, Arkhe ve Töz Kavramı Üzerine, Thales, Anaksimandros ve Anaksimenes, SDÜ Fen-Edebiyat Fakültesi Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi, No. 57, 2022, https://dergipark.org.tr/tr/pub/sufesosbil/article/1169776
- Ministry of Culture and Tourism Museums, Milet Örenyeri, https://muze.gov.tr/muze-detay?SectionId=MLT01&DistId=MLT
- Kültür Portalı, Milet Ören Yeri, https://www.kulturportali.gov.tr/turkiye/aydin/gezilecekyer/milet-oren-yeri
- Kültür Portalı, Priene Antik Kenti, https://www.kulturportali.gov.tr/turkiye/aydin/gezilecekyer/priene
- South Aegean Development Agency, Bir Aydın Seyahati (PDF), https://www.geka.gov.tr/uploads/current_publications_v/5e3a6aaa8458b-bas-tr.pdf
- Wikipedia, Thales of Miletus, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thales_of_Miletus
- Wikipedia, Eclipse of Thales, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eclipse_of_Thales
- Wikipedia, Anaximander, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anaximander
- Wikipedia, Anaximenes of Miletus, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anaximenes_of_Miletus
- Wikipedia, Hecataeus of Miletus, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hecataeus_of_Miletus
- Wikipedia, Hippodamus of Miletus, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hippodamus_of_Miletus
- Wikipedia, Miletus, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miletus
Comments
Be the first to comment
